同样，罗森斯通说，历史学家对导致10月事件的许多事情和艾森斯泰因如何处理这些事件几乎没有异议。他认为，二月革命是真正受欢迎和必要的，而临时政府却无能、低效、愚蠢或犯罪，企图继续战争。艾森斯坦对克伦斯基处理整个局势的描述也得到了历史学家的支持。Figes表示，在这次活动中，Kerensky开始以滑稽的自我重要性的姿态昂首阔步，挺起他那瘦小的胸膛，摆出一个波拿巴的姿势。罗森斯通说，艾森斯坦把克伦斯基作为一个想要成为波拿巴的人，把他的特写镜头直接切成了拿破仑的雕像，而他也不是唯一一个建议首相看到自己的英雄角色的历史学家。艾森斯坦用类似的技巧来突出科尔尼洛夫将军的无能。艾森斯坦认为，推翻临时政府的企图实际上是建立在一种误解的基础上的，而科恩利诺夫也认为自己是一个波拿巴的人物，并没有意识到大多数支持他的人都希望利用他来推翻政府。艾森斯坦把科尔尼洛夫的形象从他的肖像中剪掉，再把他的形象与之前与克伦斯基联系在一起的那尊雕像分割开。这部电影展示了将军在彼得格勒的行军是如何被布尔什维克煽动者破坏的，他们能够说服哥萨克人他野蛮的划分，苏联的“和平，土地，面包”计划并不是指彼得格勒的工人，而是包括他们在内的所有人。
澳洲人类学论文代写:艾森斯坦把克伦斯基
Similarly, Rosenstone states that historians have little dissent over much of the things that led up to the October events, or how Eisenstein handled them. The February Revolution, he contends, was truly popular and necessary, while the Provisional Government was inept, inefficient, stupid or criminal in its attempt to continue the war. Eisenstein's portrayal of Kerensky's handling of the entire situation is alsosupported by historians. Figes states that during the event, Kerensky began to strut around with comic self-importance, puffing up his puny chest and striking the pose of a Bonaparte.'Rosenstone notes Eisenstein shows Kerensky as a would-be Bonaparte, by cutting from a close-up of him directly to a statue of Napoleon, and he is hardly the only historian to suggest the prime minister saw himself in that kind of heroic role. that Eisenstein used similar techniques to highlight the ineptitude of General Kornilov. Eisenstein suggests that the attempt to overthrow the Provisional Government was really based on a misunderstanding, exacerbated by Kornliov, who also saw himself as a Bonaparte figure and did not realise that most of those supporting him did so with the hope to use him in the government's overthrow .Eisenstein presents Kornilov as yet another potential Napoleon by cutting from his image to that of the same statue previously linked to Kerensky. The film shows how the general's march on Petrograd is undermined by Bolshevik agitators, who are able to convince the Cossacks of his Savage Division that the Soviet programme of 'Peace, Land, Bread' is not meant just for the worker sof Petrograd but for everyone, including them.
